ITAT Ahmedabad Gives Taxpayer Another Chance in ₹7.60 Lakh Income Tax Case Over Duplicate PAN

bollywoodremind.com
5 Min Read

New Delhi: The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Ahmedabad Bench, has provided fresh relief to a Gujarat-based firecracker trader by allowing him another opportunity to challenge an income tax addition of ₹7.60 lakh. The tribunal has set aside the earlier appellate order and sent the matter back to the Assessing Officer (AO) for reconsideration.

The dispute involves VG Agrawal, who allegedly received two Permanent Account Numbers (PANs) because of a clerical error. The taxpayer claimed that he had already reported his entire income from the firecracker business in an income tax return filed using one PAN. However, the Income Tax Department initiated reassessment proceedings under the second PAN and treated ₹7.60 lakh as undisclosed income.

Agrawal challenged the addition, arguing that income already declared in one return should not be taxed again merely because another PAN had been allotted to him.

How Did the Duplicate PAN Create the Tax Dispute?

According to the case details, Agrawal was allotted two PANs due to an alleged administrative mistake.

For Assessment Year 2020-21, he submitted his income tax return using one of these PANs and disclosed earnings from his firecracker business. An audit report was also filed along with the return.

However, the Income Tax Department subsequently initiated reassessment proceedings under Section 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, using the other PAN.

On March 24, 2025, the Assessing Officer completed the reassessment under Section 147 read with Section 144 of the Act. The officer determined the taxpayer’s income at ₹7.60 lakh by adding the entire amount to his taxable income.

Agrawal objected to the decision, stating that the department had overlooked the income already disclosed through his return filed under the first PAN.

Bank Statements and Affidavit Submitted by Taxpayer

During the reassessment proceedings, Agrawal maintained that his business earnings had already been reported to the Income Tax Department.

To support his position, he submitted bank statements, account confirmations from the concerned parties and other relevant documents. He also provided an affidavit requesting the cancellation of the duplicate PAN, explaining that both PANs had been allotted due to an inadvertent clerical mistake.

His main argument was that the income had already been disclosed in his original return. Therefore, adding the same ₹7.60 lakh again would effectively result in double taxation of the same business income.

Despite these submissions, the Assessing Officer did not accept his explanation and retained the addition in the reassessment order.

Why Did the First Appeal Fail?

After receiving the assessment order, Agrawal approached the Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals through the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi.

However, he did not effectively participate in the appellate proceedings and failed to provide the necessary supporting evidence and detailed arguments before the authority.

The Commissioner observed that there was insufficient material to justify interfering with the Assessing Officer’s decision. As a result, the appeal was dismissed and the ₹7.60 lakh addition remained unchanged.

ITAT Ahmedabad Sends the Case Back for Fresh Assessment

Agrawal subsequently challenged the appellate decision before the ITAT Ahmedabad Bench.

After considering the matter, the tribunal set aside the order passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals and restored the case to the Assessing Officer for fresh consideration.

The decision gives Agrawal another opportunity to submit supporting documents and establish that the income from his firecracker business had already been declared under his other PAN.

However, the tribunal’s decision to remand the case does not mean that the ₹7.60 lakh addition has been permanently deleted or that the taxpayer’s explanation has been finally accepted. The Assessing Officer will now reconsider the matter after examining the taxpayer’s submissions and relevant evidence.


Disclaimer: This article is based on the case details provided and is intended solely for general news and informational purposes. The tribunal’s remand order should not be interpreted as a final decision on the tax liability. Readers should refer to the official ITAT order and consult a qualified tax professional for advice regarding individual income tax matters.

TAGGED:
Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *